American Values Degraded
The U.S. Health Care System
To heal the ailing U.S. health care system, Americans may
have to stop p thinking like Americans. That's the message of
two articles by UCLA's Dr. Marc Nuwer, a leading expert on national
health care reform, published this week in Neurology, the journal
of the American Academy of Neurology.
"Americans prize individual choice and resist limiting
care," says Nuwer, a professor of clinical neurology at
the David Geffen School of Medicine at UCLA. "We believe
that if doctors can treat very ill patients aggressively and
keep every moment of people in the last stages of life under
medical care, then they should. We choose to hold these values.
Consequently, we choose to have a more expensive system than
Europe or Canada."
Consider these statistics:
- The United States boasts the world's most expensive health
care system, yet only one-sixth of Americans are insured.
Medical expenditures exceed $2 trillion annually, making
health care the economy's largest sector, four times bigger
than national defense.
- By 2015, the U.S. government is projected to spend $4
trillion on health care, or 20 percent of the nation's gross
domestic product.
- An aging population will boost spending. Half of Medicare
costs support very sick people in their last stages of life,
and experts estimate that Medicare funds will be exhausted
by 2018.
- 31 percent of U.S. health care funds go toward administration.
"We push a lot of paper," Nuwer says. "We spend
twice as much as Canada, which has a more streamlined health
care system that demands doctors complete less paperwork."
- 10 percent of U.S. expenses are spent on "defensive
medicine" — pricey tests ordered by doctors afraid
of missing anything, however unlikely. "Doctors don't
want to be accused in court of a delayed diagnosis, so they
bend over backwards to find something — even if it's
a rare possibility — in order to cover themselves,"
Nuwer says.
Reforming the U.S. health care system with the goal of providing
universal, affordable, high-quality care will require rethinking
our overall values and paying greater attention to care-related
expenditures, according to Nuwer.
Part of the current problem, he says, is that doctors are oblivious
to the price tags of options they're prescribing for patients.
He recommends educating physicians about the costs of care,
including imaging, blood tests and specific drugs.
"Does a fancy electric wheelchair cost $500 or $50,000?"
Nuwer asks. "Most doctors have no clue. We need to give
physicians feedback about the dollar signs behind their orders."