Not All Fats Are Created Equal
Eating saturated
fats from butter, cream and meat, as well as trans fats
found in hydrogenated oils can boost our risk of cardiovascular
disease, while consuming mono-unsaturated fat can be good for
our heart.
Yet what's the effect of all these fats on our weight? Are some
better than others?
"Research on animals and some clinical trials show that
not all fats have the same effect on weight," says Nadiah
Moussavi, a Master's student from the Université de Montréal
Department of Nutrition. "Few epidemiological studies exist
on the subject and the results of those are contradictory."
The goal of the work is to see whether a connection could be
made between the prevalence of obesity and the various forms
of fat found in the 168 countries around the world.
Using statistics from the United Nations' World Health Organization,
Moussavi studied the prevalence of obesity in women aged 15
and older. For each year between 1998 and 2002, the total amount
of calories from fat was calculated for each person. What she
found was that in the countries where mono-unsaturated fats,
found in olive oil, formed an integral part of the diet, no
or few people were found to be overweight.
Countries where the obesity rate was high and the consumption
of mono-unsaturated fat low included Saudi Arabia, Egypt and
Peru. Countries such as France, Denmark and Italy showed an
ideal portrait – low rates of obesity with a high consumption
of mono-unsaturated fats.
The situation in Canada and the United States appears more
complex. In Canada, 22.2 percent of women aged 15 and over were
obese. They consumed 147 grams of fat a day, of which 59.2 grams
were mono-unsaturated. Worse, 37.8 percent of American women
were obese, and ate 152.2 grams of fat daily, of which 45.9
grams were mono-unsaturated.
Other factors, admits Moussavi, must also be taken into consideration,
such as family history, amount of exercise, consumption of fruit
and vegetables. "Our study shows that the consumption of
mono-unsaturated fats and maybe other fats also play a role,"
she says.
In her thesis, under the direction of professors Olivier Receveur
and Victor Gavino, Moussavi showed that not only did trans fats
lead to heart disease, they also could be associated with a
higher risk of obesity.