Health-Care Workers Resisting And
Fighting H1N1 Vaccine Requirements
Hospital and other healthcare workers are at the front of the
line to get the new swine flu vaccine, but many are resisting
and even fighting vaccination requirements.
The U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention cannot yet
say how many are reluctant to have the shots because the campaign
has just started. But the number may be significant given that
only about 40 percent of U.S. healthcare workers ever get vaccinated
against seasonal influenza.
A vaccination requirement sparked protests in New York this month,
and already one lawyer has filed suit to allow staffers to opt
Healthcare workers, at high risk of infection with influenza,
including swine flu, were the first offered the vaccine against
H1N1 in many states that have started vaccinating campaigns over
the past two weeks.
"It is extremely important that healthcare workers, as well
as all hospital staff, get vaccinated for both H1N1 and seasonal
flu," said Lynnae Mahaney, president of the American Society
of Health-System Pharmacists.
Mahaney's organization surveyed pharmacy directors at 341 hospitals
across the country and found only 37 percent could report vaccination
rates of more than 70 percent at their hospitals.
"That's too low," said Mahaney.
Healthcare workers such as nurses and technicians often have
the same fears the general public has about vaccines are
they tested, can they give you the flu and can they cause side-effects?
The CDC says these fears are based on myths, but doubts persist.
The Infectious Diseases Society of America has asked for all
states to mandate vaccinations for healthcare workers.
"Decades of scientific data demonstrate Food and Drug Administration-approved
influenza vaccines to be safe, effective, and cost-saving,"
the group said in a statement.
But the U.S. Health and Human Services Department is stressing
that the vaccination campaign is voluntary.
Hospital Corp. of America is requiring healthcare workers to
get vaccinated, while MedStar, which operates hospitals in the
Baltimore-Washington area, requires all staff, including clerical
workers, to be immunized.
New York state requires healthcare workers to be vaccinated against
flu, but this week attorney Patricia Finn of Piermont, New York,
filed for a temporary restraining order against Health Commissioner
Dr. Richard Daines.
Finn, whose practice specializes in clients who want to be exempt
from vaccine requirements, said her suit represents 60,000 healthcare
Last month some healthcare workers protested in the state capital,
Albany. "Let's unite to oppose mandatory H1N1 vaccinations,"
organizers wrote in a Facebook announcement.
British officials are battling similar resistance.
"We all know that uptake of the seasonal flu vaccine among
NHS staff is traditionally low," Ian Dalton, director of
flu resilience at the National Health Service, wrote in a letter
to chief executives and boards of hospitals quoted by the Guardian
"It is an NHS board responsibility that we do not find ourselves
in this position with the swine flu vaccine."
full list of h1n1 vaccine ingredients, alerts and warnings.
Reference Source 89
October 16, 2009