For
some, potentially fatal eating
disorders may have their roots
in the pages of glossy magazines.
A new study from the University
of Minnesota has found that
girls who were frequent
readers of magazine articles
about dieting and weight
loss were more likely to
engage in unhealthy weight-control
behaviors five years later.
"I'm not surprised," said
Susan Kraus, a nutritionist
with Hackensack University
Medical Center, in Hackensack,
N.J. "It's an unfortunate
situation, because too many
people are influenced by
things that look good and
that are slick and appealing
and sexy, and they may be
practicing something that's
not the most healthy to
get to the way they want
to look."
The findings come at a
time when the issue of eating
disorders is becoming an
international debate.
A string of women in South
America have recently died
of eating disorders, including
a 23-year-old teacher who
carried only 77 pounds on
her 5-foot-2-inch frame
when she died, according
to the Associated Press.
Two models have also died,
including 21-year-old Ana
Carolina Reston, of Sao
Paolo, Brazil, who died
at 5 feet 8 inches tall
and 88 pounds. She survived
on a diet of apples and
tomatoes.
And, in August, 22-year-old
Luisel Ramos had a fatal
heart attack during a fashion
show in Uruguay. She reportedly
had been subsisting on lettuce
and soft drinks.
According to the authors
of this study, which appears
in the January issue of
Pediatrics, previous
research had looked at the
effect of short-term exposure
to media but little attention
had been paid to long-term
exposure.
One previous study had
found that adolescent girls
who were randomly assigned
to receive a fashion magazine
subscription had increased
dieting, bulimic symptoms
and body dissatisfaction,
although the effect was
most pronounced in girls
with less social support
or who were already dissatisf
ied with their bodies.
For this study, the researchers
looked at eating, activity
levels, weight and other
variables in 2,516 middle-
and high-school students.
At the beginning of the
study (1999), participants
filled out surveys and had
their height and weight
measured. They were surveyed
again five years later,
in 2004.
The odds of engaging in
unhealthy weight-control
behaviors such as fasting,
skipping meals and smoking
more cigarettes was double
for adolescent girls who
were the most frequent readers
of magazine articles about
dieting and weight loss,
compared with those who
did not read such periodicals.
The odds of engaging in
extreme behaviors such as
vomiting or taking laxatives
were three times higher
in the group that read the
most, compared with those
who did not read such magazines.
No such association was
found for boys.
The authors suggested ways
to reduce girls' exposure
to these media messages
or help them read magazines
more critically.
For instance, parents could
limit daughters' access
to magazine that promote
dieting and being excessively
thin; in fact, mothers might
stop buying the magazines
themselves.
"They're saying it's the
job of the parents, particularly
the moms, of not having
some of this literature
around the house," Kraus
said.
Doctors could also remove
such magazines from their
waiting rooms, cutting off
another avenue of exposure.