Age-related
hearing loss, a common problem
among the elderly, might be
related to inadequate levels
of folic acid, European researchers
report.
The researchers found that
people who took a folic
acid supplement had less
decline in hearing low-frequency
sounds over time, compared
with people who didn't take
the supplement.
Results of the study, led
by Jane Durga, of the Cognitive
Sciences Group, Nutrition
& Health Department
at the Nestle Research Center
in Lausanne, Switzerland,
are published in the Jan.
2 issue of the Annals
of Internal Medicine.
The researchers randomly
assigned 728 older Dutch
men and women, who showed
signs of age-related hearing
loss and low folate levels,
to receive either 800 grams
of a folic acid supplement
or a placebo daily for three
years.
Durga's team chose to conduct
the study in the Netherlands
because, unlike the United
States, the Netherlands
does not fortify its food
with folic acid, a B vitamin
also known as folate. Folate
levels in study participants
were about half those found
in Americans. In the United
States, many foods contain
supplemental folic acid
because of its benefits
in protecting against birth
defects.
At the end of the trial,
the researchers found that
the ability to hear low-frequency
sound did not decrease significantly
among those taking folic
acid supplements. However,
there was no slowing in
the decline in hearing high
frequencies in either group.
The thresholds of the low
frequencies increased by
1.0 decibel in the folic
acid group and by 1.7 decibels
in the placebo group, the
researchers said.
"Folic acid supplementation
slowed the decline in hearing
of the speech frequencies
associated with aging in
a population from a country
without folic acid fortification
of food," the researchers
wrote. "The effect requires
confirmation, especially
in populations from countries
with folic acid fortification
programs."
But Robert W. Sweetow,
director of audiology at
the University of California,
San Francisco, Medical Center,
called the results "clinically
insignificant."
"I think that their conclusion
that folic acid is actually
slowing down the progression
of age-related hearing loss
is a stretch," Sweetow said.
"I would hate to say to
patients, 'You take folic
acid and the progression
of your hearing loss is
going to slow down.'"
Another expert questioned
the significance of the
finding.
"The effect is on low frequency
hearing, but most older
folks have a problem with
high frequency hearing,"
said Dr. Hinrich Staecker,
an associate professor in
the department of otolaryngology-head
& neck surgery at the
University of Kansas Medical
Center.
Staecker also noted that
the study authors didn't
look at the ability of the
participants to hear speech
clearly. "It's easier to
make stuff louder, but it's
not easy to make stuff clearer,"
he said.
Dr. Peter M. Rabinowitz,
an associate professor of
medicine at the Yale University
School of Medicine, said,
"The investigators' finding
that low-frequency, but
not high frequency, hearing
loss was reduced in the
folate supplementation group
is somewhat surprising,
since age-related hearing
loss usually affects the
higher frequencies of hearing
first and to a greater degree."
Clearly, much is not known
about nutrition and hearing,
Rabinowitz said. For example,
other studies have suggested
that genetic differences
in the metabolism of folate
may affect how someone responds
to supplementation, including
the effect of folate on
hearing loss, he said.
"While neither this study
nor the current state of
medical knowledge provide
adequate evidence for recommending
particular supplements to
prevent hearing loss, this
study provides additional
evidence of the importance
of adequate nutrition in
older adults, as well as
the potential for future
discoveries of how to slow
the aging process of the
hearing system," Rabinowitz
said.