What could the government possibly be thinking, recommending
30 to 90 minutes of exercise a day? Who has time for that?
Couch potatoes see the recommendations,
announced last week, as so unrealistic that there's no
point in trying to follow them. Busy people with jobs
and families are throwing up their hands in exasperation.
Time-use researchers and exercise
experts say we're just making excuses.
"People certainly do have the time.
There are about 40 hours a week of free time in this country,"
says John Robinson, a professor of sociology at the University
of Maryland and co-author of Time for Life:The
Surprising Way Americans Use Their Time. People are
watching TV an average of 15 to 20 hours a week, so they
have "room to carve out more time to be active."
JoAnn Manson, chief of preventive
medicine at Harvard's Brigham and Women's Hospital in
Boston and a leading researcher on the benefits of physical
activity, says: "I'm convinced from the research that
a sedentary lifestyle kills you, and moderate activity
like walking can be lifesaving. A little exercise is better
than none, but more is better than a little."
Revised Dietary Guidelines for Americans
from the Health and Human Services and Agriculture departments,
aimed at curbing the nation's growing weight problem,
recommend adults do about 60 minutes of moderate to vigorous
physical activity most days to prevent weight gain and
60 to 90 minutes of moderate daily activity for those
trying to maintain weight loss.
They call for at least 30 minutes
most days to reduce the risk of heart disease, type 2
diabetes, osteoporosis and other diseases. Earlier guidelines
only had the 30-minute recommendation.
Government research shows that only
one-third of adults make that 30-minute goal. So the chances
that a sedentary population will rise as one from its
recliner appear, well, slim.
And yet there is a hard reality to
face: About 65% of Americans weigh too much.
Some recommendations might seem "intimidating,
but they are based on science," says Russ Pate, a University
of South Carolina professor of exercise science who was
on the guidelines committee. And not everyone has to exercise
at the highest level. If you figure out which activity
level applies to you, it might not seem as daunting, he
says.
"The baseline is 30 minutes. We all
need that," he says. You can walk briskly, dance, play
tag with the kids, pace while talking on the phone, shovel
snow, shoot hoops, bike, swim or golf. The activity could
be done in 10- and 15-minute segments as long as it adds
up to 30 minutes or more.
If you're doing that much and are
still gaining weight, you probably need to do more, Pate
says, and for some people that will be as much as 60 minutes.
Those who have lost a significant amount of weight and
are trying to keep off the extra pounds might need as
much as 90 minutes.
Many exercise avoiders argue that
they don't have the time. Robinson buys this argument
only for some people. The most time-crunched are people
ages 30 to 45, parents of young children and people who
work more than 40 hours a week, he says. For almost everyone
else, leisure time is up significantly. Both men and women
have gained about five hours of free time a week since
1965. Time-use experts suggest a few reasons: Some people
are retiring earlier, some are working less, and some
spend less time on housework.
Much of that time comes in small
snatches, 15 minutes here, 30 minutes there, Robinson
says. Most people are filling up that extra time with
television.
From studying people's time-use diaries,
he finds they watch TV or work or play on the computer
three to four hours a day. About a third of the time they
are doing other activities at the same time.
And despite some research to the
contrary, Robinson says, people are more active, averaging
two to three hours a week of exercise, mostly walking.
Pate agrees that it's hard for some
folks but says most people can exercise if they make it
a priority.
"Habitual exercisers" know when they're
going to do some activity and are not just hoping it will
happen, he says. They sort of "scan through their day
in their minds in the morning" and figure out the best
time to exercise. It may be at 6 a.m. before going to
work, during their lunch hour, right after work or in
the evening with a friend. "They're able to remain active
because they make it a priority, and because they've learned
to manage their behavior and their time."
Working it into real life
Karen Nickerson, 58, of Fairfax,
Va., says she works out first thing in the morning. She
lifts weights three days a week and jogs three days. "I
can't piddle around and then go exercise. I've got to
get up and do it, and then I'm done for the day."
Joan Pond Laisney, 57, of Carlsbad,
Calif., says exercise has been key to her weight loss
in the past 18 months. At 5-foot-8, she weighs 159 pounds,
down from 204. She took USA TODAY's Weight-Loss Challenge
(dietchallenge.usatoday.com). "I devote an hour a day
to exercise. I don't let up. Nothing is going to take
that away from me. If you want to do something bad enough,
you'll find ways to make it happen."
The guidelines don't require doing
30 to 60 minutes of activity in structured exercise alone,
which would be impractical for many people, says Manson,
who is co-author of The 30-Minute Fitness Solution.
She recommends that people try to
take a brisk walk for half an hour a day (or two 15-minute
walks) and then try to accumulate the other 30 minutes
by using the stairs whenever possible, getting up and
taking regular short breaks from their desk, or walking
around the mall or their home.
A brisk walk means walking with purpose,
moving as if you're trying to get somewhere. You have
slightly harder breathing, but you are easily able to
talk.
Another way to reach the goal is
to wear a step counter and try to accumulate 10,000 steps
(about 5 miles) a day, Manson says. About 5,000 steps
could be through a structured activity such as walking
for 30 minutes, and the other 5,000 could come from moving
more throughout the day
'Small changes' for starters
Manson says the 90-minute exercise
suggestion probably applies mostly to highly motivated
people who want to be in great shape, have a lot of weight
to lose or are trying to maintain a large weight loss.
The higher goal is based, in part,
on findings from the National Weight Control Registry,
about 5,000 people who lost an average of 73 pounds and
kept off at least 30 pounds for more than six years. They
limit calories and walk about four miles a day.
Manson worries that the importance
of strength training, which can be done in 15- to 20-minute
intervals, two or three times a week, might get lost in
the debate. She recommends that time-pressed people multitask
by using the treadmill or doing weight training and other
exercises while watching their favorite TV programs.
Not all of these changes have to
be made overnight. "I would like to see us concentrate
on getting people to make small increases in walking,"
says James Hill, an obesity researcher and a founder of
America on the Move, an initiative to get people to walk
an additional 2,000 steps a day or cut 100 calories (www.americaonthemove.org).
"If you start with small changes,
many people can probably get to 60 minutes a day, but
if you start by asking for 60 minutes a day, many people
may not even try to be more active."