Older women who drink a moderate amount of alcohol
each day may be helping to keep their minds sharp, according
to researchers at Wake Forest University Baptist Medical
Center and colleagues.
"In our study, older women who drank moderate amounts
of alcohol tended to perform better on tests for cognitive
function and dementia," said Mark Espeland, Ph.D., lead
researcher. "Most of these women drank one or two drinks
per day."
The researchers used data from the Women's Health
Initiative Memory Study, a large national study to assess
the effects of hormone therapy on dementia and cognitive
function. As part of the study, women reported how much
alcohol they drank daily.
The research, which will be reported in the February
1 issue (Vol. 161, pages 228-38) of the American Journal
of Epidemiology, found that women who reported having
one or more alcohol drinks daily scored higher on tests
of cognitive function than women who reported drinking
less. Cognitive function includes concentration, language,
memory and abstract reasoning.
"Women who reported drinking one or more drinks a
day had a 40 percent lower risk of significant declines
in cognitive function over time, compared to women who
reported no alcohol intake," said Espeland, a professor
of public health sciences.
The researchers followed 4,461 women aged 65 to 79
years for an average of 4.2 years with annual Modified
Mini-Mental State Examinations (MMSE), which is a measure
of cognitive function, and other tests to detect mild
cognitive impairment and probable dementia. Dementia
occurs when memory, judgment and thinking ability decline
substantially to the point of interfering with basic
day-to-day activities.
"There are a number of reasons one might expect moderate
alcohol intake to be beneficial," Espeland says. "Some
cognitive problems are due to strokes and blood vessels
in the brain becoming blocked, and alcohol may reduce
the development of blood clots and increase blood flow,
thereby improving cognition."
Espeland said alcohol also tends to increase levels
of high-density lipoprotein, or "good" cholesterol,
which might also reduce the risk for narrowed vessels
in the brain. In addition, alcohol may decrease the
formation of plaque that is associated with Alzheimer's
disease.
Previous studies have also indicated that moderate
levels of alcohol intake reduce the risk of dementia
and decline in cognitive function. Espeland said, however,
that the results must be interpreted with caution.
"While evidence is growing that alcohol is beneficial
in this area, it is still unclear whether alcohol intake
or another defining characteristic is the reason for
reduced risk," he said.
The researchers adjusted for other factors that might
affect the results, such as education level and family
income, and still found the same pattern of moderate
alcohol intake associated with better cognitive function
and less risk of dementia.
"But we cannot rule out that unmeasured factors affected
cognition," he said. "My sense is that for older women
who choose to drink – and are not restricted from drinking
for medical reasons – moderate alcohol intake is not
harmful for cognition and may provide some benefits
by reducing the risk of cognitive decline.
"Until we better understand the reasons why alcohol
consumption is associated with better cognitive functioning,
however, these results on their own are not a reason
for people who don't drink to start or for those who
drink less to increase their intake."