Being cynical can increase the risk of heart
disease, US researchers claim.
A study of 6,814 people found that cynical
distrust was associated with signs of inflammation which in
turn increase the risk of heart disease.
Chronic stress and depression were also found
to be associated with higher levels of certain inflammatory
markers in the blood.
The Archives of Internal Medicine study suggests
cynical people are more likely to lead unhealthy lifestyles.
Researchers from the University of Michigan
asked participants to fill out a questionnaire that assessed
a person's risk of chronic stress or depression.
Cynical distrust was
measured at a later follow-up visit.
They also took blood samples from participants
who were aged between 45 ane 84 years.
The samples were analysed for three markers
of inflammation - fibrinogen, C-reactive protein, and IL-6.
Higher levels of cynical distrust were associated
with higher levels of all three inflammatory markers.
Chronic stress was linked with higher levels
of IL-6 and C-reactive protein and depression was associated
with higher levels of IL-6.
"The strongest and most consistent associations
were observed for cynical distrust, which was positively associated
with all three inflammatory markers," said study leader Dr
Nalini Ranjit.
Inflammation
Previous studies have reported links between
psychosocial factors such as stress and cardiovascular disease.
However, the reason for this is unclear.
Inflammation is an important pathway in the
development of atherosclerosis - a process where the arteries
become narrow and hardened blocking blood flow - and in heart
attacks and strokes.
When Dr Ranjit and colleagues analysed the
findings in more detail they found that much of the increase
in inflammatory markers was linked to unhealthy lifestyle
factors, such as obesity and smoking.
They concluded that cynical people might
be more likely to indulge in unhealthy behaviour, and that
it was this that could explain their higher risk of heart
disease.
Vicky Styman, a cardiac nurse at the British
Heart Foundation, said there was insufficient evidence to
say that emotion was a significant risk factor for heart disease.
She said: "One difficulty is that emotions
are subjective. Some people thrive on stress while others
prefer a slower pace, and it is often how people deal with
stress that can increase their risk of heart disease rather
than the stress itself.
"It is particularly difficult to define if
someone is cynical and measure what impact this has on their
likelihood to develop disease.
"As the authors of this study acknowledge,
psychological factors such as stress can often lead to unhealthy
behaviours, including smoking, eating an unhealthy diet and
physical inactivity - all of which are established risk factors
for heart disease."