While neither men nor women
may be the more intelligent sex, their brains may take
different paths to reach the same intellectual level,
according to one team of researchers.
Their study found that
among men and women who performed equally on intelligence
tests, women had far more intelligence-related white
matter in their brains than men did, while men surpassed
women when it came to intelligence-related gray matter.
Gray matter can be seen
as the brain's "information processing centers," whereas
white matter is like the wiring connecting those centers,
said Dr. Richard J. Haier, a professor of psychology
at the University of California, Irvine, and the study's
lead author.
The findings suggest
that women and men may have "fundamentally different
brain architectures" underlying intelligence. "It has
nothing to do with men being more intelligent than women,
or women being more intelligent than men," Haier said.
Instead, according to
the researcher, men and women may draw upon different
brain designs to arrive at the same intellectual capacity.
That possibility is of more than a scientific interest,
Haier noted; it could help researchers better understand
sex differences in stroke and degenerative brain diseases
like Alzheimer's disease.
The study, published
online January 16, 2005 in the journal NeuroImage, involved
48 men and women between 18 and 84 years old who took
a standard battery of IQ tests and had MRI brain scans
to gauge the volume of white and gray matter in different
brain areas related to intelligence.
Overall, the researchers
found, men and women performed equally on the IQ tests.
However, the brain structures involved in intelligence
appeared distinct.
Compared with women,
men had more than six times the amount of intelligence-related
gray matter, while women had about nine times more white
matter involved in intelligence than men did.
In addition, women had
a large proportion of their IQ-related brain matter
-- both white and gray -- concentrated in the brain's
frontal lobes, a region at the front of the brain involved
in movement, emotions and higher functions such as speech,
reasoning and judgment.
Men, on the other hand,
had 90 percent of their IQ-related gray matter distributed
equally between the frontal lobes and the parietal lobes
-- a region right behind the frontal lobes involved
in sensory perception, such as taste and touch, and
skills, such as reading and math.
In addition, the large
majority of the men's IQ-related white matter -- 82
percent -- was found to dwell in a third brain region,
the temporal lobes. These lobes govern functions such
as perceiving sound and processing memories.
According to Haier, the
fact that women's IQ-related brain matter was more centralized
in the frontal lobes may help explain why strokes affecting
this brain area appear to inflict more damage in women
than men.
Whether the different
brain designs translate into differences in specific
intellectual skills, like math or language, is unknown.
It's possible, according to Haier, that the findings
offer one explanation for the stereotypical male predilection
for numbers and spatial questions and female preference
for language.
But, as he pointed out,
that's a complex and controversial issue.
Earlier this month, Harvard
University president Lawrence Summers caused a stir
when he suggested that "innate differences" between
men and women could be one reason women are underrepresented
in the upper strata of the science and engineering fields.
When it comes to sex
differences found in the brain, though, the degree to
which they are inborn is not necessarily clear. As Haier
and his colleagues note in their report, there is evidence
that the volume of the brain's gray matter can increase
with learning, and therefore may be a matter of environment
as well as genes.
SOURCE: NeuroImage, online
January 16, 2005.