The timing of systemic chemotherapy in patients with
breast cancer does not affect patient survival or disease
progression, say researchers reporting in the Feb. 2
issue of the Journal of the National Cancer Institute.
However, the study did find that breast cancer patients
who receive systemic therapy and radiation therapy without
surgery may be more likely to suffer cancer recurrence
than women treated with chemotherapy after surgery.
The findings may be important, since a growing number
of breast cancer patients are undergoing what's called
'"neoadjuvant" chemotherapy -- drug therapy given in
the weeks before surgery to help shrink tumor size and
reduce the amount of tissue removed.
Researchers at the Ioannina School of Medicine, in
Greece, analyzed data from nine studies of almost 4,000
breast cancer patients who'd received systemic therapy
either before or after surgery and/or radiation treatment.
They found no difference between neoadjuvant and adjuvant
(post-surgical) systemic therapy in terms of death,
disease progression or distant recurrence of cancer.
But the researchers did find that neoadjuvant therapy
was associated with a 22 percent increased risk of local
cancer recurrence compared with adjuvant therapy. The
risk of recurrence was 53 percent greater when radiation
therapy was used without surgery.
The study "demonstrates the equivalence of neoadjuvant
and adjuvant treatments for breast cancer in terms of
survival, disease progression," the study authors write
in a prepared statement.
They add that neoadjuvant treatment may be associated
with an increased risk of local tumor recurrence, however,
"especially when primary systemic treatment is not accompanied
by any surgical intervention."
"Consequently, we recommend avoiding the use of radiotherapy
without any surgical treatment, even in the presence
of an apparently good clinical response to neoadjuvant
chemotherapy," the researchers conclude.
The U.S. National Cancer Institute has more about breast
cancer treatment .