Working mothers in the United States can relax. Their kids
might still get into Harvard. A study from researchers at
the University of Texas at Austin found no differences in
children's social and intellectual development during the
first three years of life between those whose mothers spent
a lot of time with them in infancy and those whose mothers
spent less time because they worked outside the home. The
results were published in the March/April 2005 issue of
the journal Child Development.
The findings are significant because more than half of
American infants have mothers who are employed at least
part-time during their child's first year of life. Many
psychologists and parents worry that the time mothers spend
away from their babies when at work detracts from mothers'
ability to be sensitive to their babies' needs and to provide
cognitive stimulation to their children.
Aletha C. Huston, PhD, and Stacey Rosenkrantz Aronson,
PhD, analyzed 24-hour diaries of time use from 1,053 mothers
of infants collected in the National Institute of Child
Health and Human Development Study of Early Child Care.
They also examined videotaped observations of mothers interacting
with their babies to measure how sensitive mothers were
to their children's needs and visited the mothers' homes
to observe the quality of the home environment.
They found that although mothers who were employed spent
less time with their infants than nonemployed mothers, the
employed women compensated by spending more time with their
children on weekends and decreasing the time spent in housework,
leisure, outside organizations, travel, and social activities.
As expected, mothers who spent more of their available time
with their babies (regardless of employment status) were
slightly more sensitive and provided higher quality home
environments, but mothers' personalities, beliefs, and family
circumstances were much more important than time as predictors
of their parenting.
Overall, the researchers found, whether or not mothers
worked during their child's first three years had no effect
on their child's social and intellectual development during
those three years.
"The amount of time that mothers spend with their babies
and at work are not the critical determinants of strong,
positive mother-child relationships," said Dr. Huston. "Instead,
mothers' personality characteristics, beliefs, and family
circumstances affect both time allocation and parenting
behavior. Mothers who give priority to spending time with
their infants, whether or not they are also employed, are
more likely to provide sensitive, high-quality parenting.
And almost all of the mothers interacted enough with their
children for normal development to occur during the first
three years of life."