People on strict raw food vegetarian
diets are thin but healthy, U.S. researchers reported.
Although nutritionists and
the food industry have warned that a diet without dairy
foods can lead to the bone-thinning disease osteoporosis,
the team at Washington University School of Medicine in
St. Louis found the vegans they studied had many of the
signs of strong bones.
Dr. Luigi Fontana, who led
the study, said they had thin bones but none of the other
signs of osteoporosis.
"We think it's possible these
people don't have increased risk of fracture but that their
low bone mass is related to the fact that they are lighter
because they take in fewer calories," Fontana said in a
statement.
He said he would continue
to follow them to see if they develop osteoporosis later.
"Raw food vegetarians believe
in eating only plant-derived foods that have not been cooked,
processed, or otherwise altered from their natural state,"
Fontana's team wrote in this week's issue of the Archives
of Internal medicine.
"Because of their low calorie
and low protein intake, raw food vegetarians have a low
body mass index (BMI) and a low total body fat content.
It is well documented that a low BMI and weight loss are
strongly associated with low bone mass and increased fracture
risk, while obesity protects against osteoporosis."
Fontana's team studied 18
strict raw food vegans aged 33 to 85. All ate a diet that
included unprepared foods such vegetables, fruits, nuts,
and sprouted grains. They had been on this diet for an average
of 3.6 years.
The team compared them to
18 more average Americans. The raw food group had an average
body mass index of 20.5, while the average group were slightly
overweight with a BMI of 25.
BMI is an internationally
accepted measurement of height to weight, and a BMI of 18.5
to 24 is considered the healthy range.
Fontana expected the vegans
to have low vitamin D levels because they avoid dairy products,
which are fortified with the vitamin. But in fact their
vitamin D levels were "markedly higher" than average.
Vitamin D is made by the
skin when the body is exposed to sunlight and is key to
keeping strong bones.
"These people are clever
enough to expose themselves to sunlight to increase their
concentrations of vitamin D," Fontana said.
And the vegans had low levels
of C-reactive protein, an inflammatory molecule that is
becoming linked with the risk of heart disease, diabetes
and other chronic disease.
Furthermore, they had lower
levels of IGF-1, a growth factor linked to risk of breast
and prostate cancer.
Fontana does not advocate
a raw food diet. But he said that to lower the risk of cancer
and heart disease people should eat more fruits, vegetables
and whole grains.