Milk's poor reputation as being
an unhealthy drink may be unjustified, research suggests.
Scientists found drinking milk does
not increase the risk of heart disease and stroke
- in fact it may even have a protective effect.
The researchers, from the University
of Bristol, found men who consumed at least 200ml
a day were less likely to develop ischaemic heart
disease.
The study is published in the Journal
of Epidemiology and Community Health.
Writing in the journal, the researchers
say that milk has had a bad press as it increases
cholesterol levels.
Also, research has suggested rates
of fatal heart disease are highest in countries who
drink the most milk.
However, they say: "The present perception
of milk as harmful, in increasing cardiovascular risk,
should be challenged, and every effort should be made
to restore it to its rightful place in a healthy diet."
The findings are based on data from
665 men from south Wales, aged 45-59, who kept detailed
diaries of their food and drink consumption, and who
underwent regular health checks over a period of 20
years.
During the study period, 54 had a
stroke and 139 developed symptoms of ischaemic heart
disease, such as a heart attack or angina. In total
225 died.
Men who drank the most milk had a
lower risk of ischaemic heart disease, and a significantly
lower risk of stroke than those who drank the least.
Energy
The researchers also found men who
consumed the most milk every day had a higher energy
intake - suggesting that they were more active.
Cholesterol levels and blood pressure
readings were similar in high and low milk consumers.
However, those men who drank the
least milk - less than 200ml a day - tended to drink
the most alcohol.
Researcher Dr Andy Ness told the
BBC News website it was possible, but unlikely, that
the differences uncovered in the study were nothing
to do with milk consumption.
Alternatively, although milk contained
saturated fats, which are known to be bad for health,
it could be that this negative effect was counter-balanced
by beneficial ingredients. For instance, calcium has
been shown to lower blood pressure.
Dr Ness said it was also possible
that milk displaced other, potentially more damaging
food and drink, in some people's diets.
Starting young
Finally, it was also possible that
men enjoyed milk as adults also drank significant
quantities as child - when it is known to play a crucial
role in healthy development.
He said: "I would not encourage people
to drink pints and pints of milk, but as part of balanced
diet some milk does not appear to be harmful."
Claire Williamson, a nutrition scientist
at the British Nutrition Foundation, said milk and
dairy foods were an important part of a balanced diet.
"Milk is an important source of several
nutrients including protein, calcium, zinc and vitamin
B12.
"Currently around 5% of men and 8%
of women aged between 19-24 years are not consuming
enough calcium to meet their needs."
She recommended two to three servings
per day - a serving is a 200ml glass of milk, a small
pot of yogurt or a 30g portion of cheese.
At the start of the study, virtually
all milk consumption was whole (full fat) milk.
But a random sample of the surviving
men in 2000, showed that almost all had switched to
skimmed or semi skimmed milk.