Americans' widening waistlines are the main force behind
rising U.S. health care costs, a new study shows.
Between 1987 and 2002, the proportion of private health
spending attributable to obesity increased more than tenfold,
researchers report, from $3.6 billion to $36.5 billion.
In the year 2002, obesity-related medical care spending
accounted for 11.6 percent of all private health care spending
compared to just 2 percent in 1987, concludes an article
published today in Health Affairs.
"We can focus on obesity and we should be," said study
lead author, Kenneth Thorpe, the Robert W. Woodruff professor
and chair of the department of health policy and management
at Emory University in Atlanta. "We need to have the same
type of societal attention on this issue that we gave to
smoking 20 years ago," Thorpe added.
There's been no question that health care costs in this
country are soaring. The question has been, "Why?"
"You can break health care spending into two things," Thorpe
explained. "One is that we're treating more people who are
sick, and second is that it costs more to treat those patients."
To find out which factor was predominant, Thorpe and his
colleagues looked at data from the 1987 National Medical
Expenditure Survey and the 2002 Medical Expenditure Panel
Survey, both nationally representative samples. Specifically,
they were concerned with spending among privately insured
adults aged 18 to 64 for the top 20 medical conditions.
As it turned out, more than half of the growth in health
care spending was attributable to increased prevalence of
disease rather than an increase in how much it cost to treat
each person.
"We found overwhelmingly that the rise in private insurance
spending was traced to the fact that we were treating more
and more people with a variety of chronic health conditions,"
Thorpe said.
In other words, more people are sick now than before; predominantly
with conditions linked to obesity such as diabetes and high
blood pressure. This means that in 2001, obese adults with
private health insurance spent $1,244 more per person per
year on health care than normal-weight adults. Back in 1987,
that number was just $272.
Obese individuals are being treated for more conditions,
too, the study found. In 2001, for example, 15.5 percent
of obese adults were treated for six or more medical conditions,
nearly double the 1987 percentage.
There have also been changes in the way clinicians treat
patients. "They're more likely to give you a blood pressure
pill today at a lower threshold than 15 years ago," Thorpe
said.
Finally, new, expensive technology is also driving costs
upwards, the study found.
"Obesity is a very expensive health problem and, unlike
some other health problems, doesn't appear to be topping
out. It appears to be accelerating," said Dr. Tom Farley,
co-author of Prescription for a Healthy Nation and
professor of community health sciences at Tulane University
School of Public Health and Tropical Medicine in New Orleans.
"We all pay for these costs," Farley pointed out. "It's
not just people who are obese. All of us have higher premiums,
higher taxes. This is a society-wide problem and we need
society-wide solutions."
Unfortunately, the debate on how to curb this growth in
obesity and its related expense is focusing on the wrong
issues, Thorpe said.
"The private insurers are doing nothing to deal with this
issue," he said. "They're looking at consumer-driven plans,
increasing co-pays. If you think about it, those are going
to do nothing to affect the 60 percent increase in diabetes."
Rather than trying to decrease the cost per case, we need
to look at the bigger picture, he said.
"We're looking under the wrong light here," Thorpe said.
"We need to fundamentally focus our attention on how to
control costs."