Overweight Kids Face Widespread Stigma
Overweight children are stigmatized
by their peers as early as age 3 and even face bias from their
parents and teachers, giving them a quality of life comparable
to people with cancer, a new analysis concludes.
Youngsters who report teasing, rejection, bullying and other
types of abuse because of their weight are two to three times
more likely to report suicidal thoughts as well as to suffer from
other health issues such as high blood pressure and eating disorders,
"The stigmatization directed at obese children by their peers,
parents, educators and others is pervasive and often unrelenting,"
researchers with Yale University
and the University of Hawaii
at Manatoa wrote in the July issue of Psychological Bulletin.
The paper was based on a review of all research on youth weight
bias over the past 40 years, said lead author Rebecca M. Puhl
of Yale's Rudd Center for Food Policy and Obesity.
It comes amid a growing worldwide epidemic of child obesity.
By 2010, almost 50 percent of children in North
America and 38 percent of children in the European
Union will be overweight, the researchers said.
While programs to prevent childhood obesity are growing, more
efforts are needed to protect overweight
children from abuse, Puhl said.
"The quality of life for kids who are obese is comparable to
the quality of life of kids who have cancer," Puhl said, citing
one study. "These kids are facing stigma from everywhere they
look in society, whether it's media, school or at home."
Even with a growing percentage of overweight people, the stigma
shows no signs of subsiding, according to Puhl. She said television
and other media continue to reinforce negative stereotypes.
"This is a form of bias that is very socially acceptable," Puhl
said. "It is rarely challenged; it's often ignored."
The stigmatization of overweight children has been documented
for decades. When children were asked to rank photos of children
as friends in a 1961 study, the overweight child was ranked last.
Children as young as 3 are more likely to consider overweight
peers to be mean, stupid, ugly and sloppy.
A growing body of research shows that parents and educators are
also biased against heavy children. In a 1999 study of 115 middle
and high school teachers, 20 percent said they believed obese
people are untidy, less likely to succeed and more emotional.
"Perhaps the most surprising source of weight stigma toward youths
is parents," the report says.
Several studies showed that overweight girls got less college
financial support from their parents than average weight girls.
Other studies showed teasing by parents was common.
"It is possible that parents may take out their frustration,
anger and guilt on their overweight child by adopting stigmatizing
attitudes and behavior, such as making critical and negative comments
toward their child," the authors wrote, suggesting further research
Lynn McAfee, 58, of Stowe,
Pa., said that as an overweight child she faced troubles on all
"It was constantly impressed upon me that I wasn't going to get
anywhere in the world if I was fat," McAfee said. "You hear it
so often, it becomes the truth."
Her mother, who also was overweight, offered to buy her a mink
coat when she was 8 to try to get her to lose weight even though
her family was poor.
"I felt I was letting everybody down," she said.
Other children would try to run her down on bikes to see if
she would bounce. She had a hard time getting on teams in the
"Teachers did not stand up for me when I was teased," McAfee
A study in 2003 found that obese children had much lower quality
of life scores on issues such as health, emotional and social
well-being, and school functioning.
"An alarming finding of this research was that obese children
had (quality of life) scores comparable with those of children
with cancer," the researchers reported.
Sylvia Rimm, author of "Rescuing the Emotional Lives of Overweight
Children," said her surveys of more than 5,000 middle
school children reached similar conclusions.
"The overweight children felt
less intelligent," Rimm said. "They felt less popular. They struggled
from early on. They feel they are a different species."
Parents should emphasize a child's strengths, she said, and
teachers should pair up students for activities instead of letting
children pick their partners.
McAfee, who now works for the Council on Size and Weight Discrimination,
said her childhood experiences even made her reluctant to see
a doctor when she needed one. She recalled one doctor who said
she looked like a gorilla and another who gave her painkillers
and diet pills for what turned out to be mononucleosis.
"The amount of cruelty I've seen in people has changed me forever,"
The Yale-Hawaii research report recommends more research to
determine whether negative stereotypes lead to discriminatory
behavior, citing evidence that overweight adults face discrimination.
It also calls for studying ways to reduce stigma and negative
attitudes toward overweight children.
"Weight-based discrimination is as important a problem as racial
discrimination or discrimination against children with physical
disabilities," the report concludes. "Remedying it needs to be
taken equally seriously..."