|
Cranberry Juice Not A Good
Kidney Stone Defense
Cranberry juice may be a popular home remedy for urinary
tract infections , but new research suggests it's of little
use against another urinary tract woe: kidney
stones .
In fact, researchers found, the beverage may slightly increase
a susceptible person's risk of the most common type of kidney
stone.
Their study, of 24 people with and without a history of kidney
stones, found that cranberry juice tended to boost urinary levels
of calcium and oxalate, two major components of kidney stones.
Indeed, the large majority of stones are composed mainly of calcium.
The juice did reduce substances that contribute to an uncommon
type of stone, but on balance, the findings suggest that people
should find a different tactic for fighting kidney stones, according
to study co-author Dr. Margaret S. Pearle of the University of
Texas Southwestern Medical Center in Dallas. [
People who tend to be "stone formers" would be better off reaching
for orange juice, which does appear to fight the problem, Pearle
stated. In general, she noted, susceptible people should drink
plenty of fluids to help prevent kidney stone formation.
The stones develop when certain dissolved substances in the
urine, including calcium, uric acid and oxalate, begin to crystallize
and form into hard masses in the kidneys. The stones travel to
the bladder and, if they're small enough, are passed without
a problem. In some cases, though, they block the tube that connects
the kidneys and bladder, causing symptoms such as pain in the
lower abdomen and back, a frequent urge to urinate and pain during
urination.
Cranberry juice has long been espoused as a home remedy for
recurrent urinary tract infections, and a number of studies have
supported that notion. Pearle said many of the kidney stone patients
she sees have told her they drink plenty of cranberry juice to
help prevent the problem from recurring.
Where they got the idea that this works, according to Pearle,
is unclear, so she and her colleagues decided to study the matter.
They had 24 adults drink 1 liter of cranberry juice per day
for one week and spend another week drinking a liter of water
each day. On the last two days of each week, the researchers
collected urine samples for analysis.
Overall, cranberry juice increased participants' urinary levels
of calcium and oxalate, a substance found in foods such as coffee,
nuts, chocolate, spinach and wheat bran. Calcium oxalate climbed
by 18 percent, on average.
Calcium oxalate stones are the most common subtype of kidney
stones, Pearle noted, so the findings suggest that cranberry
juice could actually increase a susceptible person's risk of
developing stones.
Cranberry juice contains calcium and vitamin C,
which is converted to oxalate in the body, and this may explain
the increase in urinary calcium oxalate, according to Pearle.
The beverage did reduce the presence of a substance called brushite
in the urine, indicating possible protection against brushite
stones. However, Pearle said, these masses are a relatively rare
subtype of kidney stone.
In a final strike against the cranberry, the juice did not show
the potentially protective effect of increasing urinary citrate,
as orange and grapefruit juices have been shown to do.
So if you're going to turn to juice for kidney stone relief,
Pearle said, cranberry juice probably shouldn't be the choice.
SOURCE: Journal of Urology, August 2005.
Reference
Source 89
August
24,
2005
For more information on how to prevent other diseases, use
PreventDisease.com's "Quick
Prevention Resources".
|
