Drugs often used to treat elderly
patients with dementia-related aggression and delusions
can raise their risk of death, according to a study that
reinforces new warning labels required on the medications.
The researchers
pooled results of 15 previous studies on drugs known as
atypical anti-psychotics and sold under the brand names
Zyprexa, Risperdal, Seroquel and Abilify.
Among
more than 5,000 elderly dementia patients, those taking
any of the drugs faced a 54 percent increased risk of
dying within 12 weeks of starting the medication, compared
with patients taking dummy pills.
There were 118 deaths among the 3,353
drug users versus 40 in the 1,757-patient placebo group,
or 3.5 percent compared with 2.3 percent. The risks were
similar for each of the drugs.
The drugs
are approved for treating schizophrenia and bipolar disease,
not elderly dementia. But because schizophrenia-like symptoms
are common in elderly patients with Alzheimer's disease
or other dementia, doctors frequently prescribe the drugs
to these patients, too. Such "off-label" uses are legal.
The study
gave no information on the causes of death, but the Food
and Drug Administration warned in April that the drugs
have been linked to deaths from heart failure and pneumonia
in elderly dementia patients. At the FDA's request, manufacturers
recently revised their drug labels to include strong warnings
of the increased risk of death.
Dr. Lon
Schneider, a University of Southern California psychiatrist
and the study's lead author, said the results should instill
caution "but not a great sense of fear."
"These
drugs are clinically needed and there are actually few
alternatives" for elderly dementia patients, Schneider
said.
Withholding
the drugs from patients who need them could also prove
dangerous, by increasing the chances they might harm themselves
and others, he said.
The study
appears in the Journal of the American Medical Association.
Dr. Ronald
Landbloom of Zyprexa maker Eli Lilly & Co. said the
drugs "can be very helpful with aggressive psychotic patients
who are beating up caregivers and nursing home staff,
and hurting themselves," but doctors need to be aware
of the risks.
William
Thies, scientific director of the Alzheimer's Association,
said up to about half of all Alzheimer's patients develop
problems the drugs can treat.
"The trade-off
is clearly going to be this small risk," and for some
patients, the risk is worth taking, Thies said.
- More articles
on preventing Dementia