Acupuncture
Gains Acceptance,
Application in Western Medicine
Excerpt
By Melinda
T. Willis, ABCNews.com
When you're in pain, the prospect of having someone stick needles
into your body may not seem like the greatest of ideas. Yet millions
of people who visit acupuncturists each year are doing just that.
Increasingly, research experience is showing Western practitioners
that when it comes to certain conditions, acupuncture can be just
as effective as conventional treatments like medications.
"It's not so much that acupuncture is used in every instance
to eliminate drugs. It may be used to reduce reliance on drug
therapy as a way to deal with symptoms," says James Dowden, executive
administrator at the American Academy of Medical Acupuncture,
a professional society of physicians who are trained to practice
acupuncture and seek to incorporate it into their practice. "It
becomes an alternative way to address a chronic condition."
Acupuncture has been used for thousands of years by Chinese
practitioners for a wide array of ailments, but it is only recently
that it has moved from the fringe of Western medicine.
A critical moment came in 1975, when New York Times
reporter James Reston wrote about his experiences with acupuncture
to relieve pain following an appendectomy in China. "That really
started to open the gates for the first time to the West considering
acupuncture as anything other than something bizarre and off the
beaten path," says Dr. James Dillard, assistant clinical professor,
Columbia University College of Physicians and Surgeons in New
York.
The first license was granted to an acupuncturist in the United
States the next year. Yet until 1995, the Food and Drug Administration
officially considered acupuncture needles to be experimental medical
instruments.
Further strides were made in moving acupuncture towards the
center of heath care in 1997, when the National Institutes of
Health released a consensus statement on acupuncture in which
a 20-member panel endorsed its use for pain and nausea and suggested
it may be helpful in other conditions.
"Since that time, and certainly with the increasing interest
in alternative and complementary medicine, there has been an increase
in published literature on acupuncture," says Dillard. "Instead
of tens of papers, we now have hundreds of papers in the literature
and more in the pipeline."
It's Ancient History
As scientists continue their quest to understand the potential
uses of acupuncture and how it relates to Western medicine, they
are also striving to understand more about acupuncture's great
mystery to figure out precisely how the simple insertion
of a handful of tiny needles under the skin can bring about physiological
changes in the body.
The ancient Chinese belief about acupuncture is that humans
have energy or "qi" (pronounced "chee") running through channels
in our bodies called meridians and ill health is related to a
blockage in the flow of this energy.
"The idea is that you put a needle on a point along the meridian
and hopefully stimulate the points to reopen the channels," explains
Lixing Lao, a licensed acupuncturist and associate professor in
the Complementary Medicine Program at the University of Maryland
in Baltimore.
"The meridians are not only distributed on the surface, but
they also connect to the internal organs," he adds. "So that's
why stimulating the points on the surface can stimulate the organs
inside."
There are more than 2000 of these acupuncture points distributed
on the body. Stimulation of the right sequence of these points
is thought to be effective in addressing certain problems.
The Connective Tissue Connection
So how do scientists think that these hair-thin needles can
make you feel better? One of the most widely accepted theories
of acupuncture is that the needles stimulate endorphins
the feel good chemicals associated with the "runners high."
"When you perform the acupuncture treatment, there is a release
of endorphins that have the effect of increasing the sense of
well-being and making the patient feel better," explains Dowden.
This theory may explain why acupuncture relieves pain and stress
and why some studies suggest it may help depression. Other theories
speculate that acupuncture may increase one's threshold of pain,
thereby making people better able to tolerate it later on.
Other researchers have focused on what happens when needle meets
tissue in the hands of an experienced practitioner.
"When the needle is inserted into the tissue in acupuncture,
the acupuncturist manipulates the needle for a certain amount
of time to achieve a certain reaction called de qi [day chee],"
says Dr. Helene Langevin, a licensed acupuncturist and research
assistant professor in the department of neurology at the University
of Vermont in Burlington. This sensation is compared in ancient
Chinese texts to a fish tugging on a fishing line.
"We found in animal studies that connective tissue tends to
wind around the needle when it is rotated," adds Langevin. "All
it takes is a small amount of winding and after that any movement
of the needle will pull on connective tissue."
This pull on connective tissue may be sending mechanical signals
to the surrounding cells, including cells of the nervous system,
which may further explain its mechanism of action. The next step,
according to Langevin, will be to find out what is happening on
a cellular and molecular level.
Moving Into Mainstream
One of the reasons that acupuncture has been so well-embraced
in the West may have to do with its low rate of side effects.
"For a medical procedure, you almost cannot get anything that
is more benign," says Dowden. "About the worst thing that can
happen is you won't get better."
Side effects include minor bleeding, bruising, and lightheadedness.
Extremely rare is the possibility of a collapsed lung, which experts
say is highly uncommon and only likely to happen with careless
practitioners.
"In hospitals, we put a regular venipuncture needle right into
somebody's artery and take a blood specimen and put our finger
over it for a minute to stop the bleeding," reasons Dr. Woodson
Merrell, a physician acupuncturist and director for the Center
for Health and Healing at Beth Israel Medical Center in New York
City. "Compare this to an acupuncture needle, where you can fit
half a dozen of them over the whole of the needle used to [take
blood]. Because of that the risk of side effects is very uncommon."
However, because these risks are even lower for experienced
acupuncturists, Merrell offers tips on how to find a well-credentialed
practitioner.
"Even if somebody has a license, that doesn't mean that they're
good," he cautions. " [But] being a member of a state association
shows that they're actively involved in getting continuing education
credits, and someone who has been in practice for a number of
years and have some experience under their belt."
Additionally some states have online sites where you can check
to see if there are any actions being taken against practitioners.
And don't discount good old-fashioned word of mouth as more and
more people seek out acupuncturists as an effective, low-risk
way to approach their health problems.
"Ten years ago, it was probably considered in the quackery area
by the more conservative physicians," says Merrell. "Now it's
being considered as a practice that people can think of for patients
the same way that they can think of giving a drug or physical
therapy or surgery. Eventually it will just be part of mainstream
care."
Reference
Source 104
For more information on how to prevent other diseases, use
PreventDisease.com's "Quick
Prevention Resources".
|