Exercise
Beats Drugs For
Some With Depression
NEW YORK (Reuters
Health) - Besides its physical health benefits, exercise is often
said to help people simply feel good. And a growing number of
studies are showing that these mood-boosting effects may even
fight clinical depression.
The latest
evidence that exercise can be an antidepressant comes from a German
study of 12 men and women with major depression. Researchers found
that walking for 30 minutes each day quickly improved the patients'
symptoms--faster, in fact, than antidepressant drugs typically
do, according to a report in the April issue of the British Journal
of Sports Medicine.
Dr. Fernando
Dimeo and his colleagues at Freie University in Berlin measured
the patients' depressive symptoms before and after 10 days of
treadmill workouts. The investigators found that by the study's
end, 6 of the 12 patients had improved significantly and 2 had
improved slightly. Five of these patients had failed to benefit
from antidepressant drugs, the authors note.
``Our results
indicate that, in selected patients with major depression, aerobic
training can produce a substantial improvement in symptoms in
a short time,'' the researchers write.
Previous studies
have suggested that exercise is a potent mood-booster, and some
research indicates that for some patients regular activity may
be a better depression treatment than psychotherapy or medication.
Exactly why is unclear, but exercise does influence certain mood-related
hormones. And it is also believed to enhance people's sense of
control over their lives.
In one study
that compared exercise with antidepressants among older adults,
investigators found that physical activity was the more effective
depression-fighter. That study's lead author, Dr. James A. Blumenthal
of Duke University in Durham, North Carolina, told Reuters Health
that exercise is potentially an important component of depression
treatment.
But, he said,
``one treatment may not work for everyone, and it's important
to match the right treatment to the right person.''
Blumenthal
called the current study findings ``provocative,'' but noted that
he and his colleagues have found that it typically takes at least
1 month of regular exercise before patients' moods improve.
Exercise is
gaining more research interest as a way to battle depression,
according to Blumenthal.
``Depression
is so prevalent and can be so debilitating,'' he said, ``that
alternative treatments do need to be looked at.'' It is important
that such studies have the ``scientific rigor'' to show exercise
is a valid treatment option, he added.
SOURCE:
British Journal of Sports Medicine 2001;35:114-117.
Reference
Source 89
For
more information on how to prevent other diseases, use
PreventDisease.com's "Quick
Prevention Resources".
|