The
Power Game: He Says, She Does
Excerpt
By Colette Bouchez, HealthScoutNews
(HealthScoutNews) -- Women climb the power tree differently then
men, but they reach the top just the same.
That's the conclusion of a new study, which found that while
men establish dominance from the moment they enter a situation,
women move more slowly, forming alliances that ultimately help
them achieve their power.
"It has always been thought that women take a more evenhanded
approach to group settings, allowing for a more even exchange
of ideas between all participants, while men assume a hierarchical
dominant approach, with one man emerging as the leader almost
right from the start, and others in the group falling into place
below him," says study author Marianne Schmid Mast, a researcher
at Northeastern University in Boston.
What's more, Mast adds, it has been traditionally thought that
because women approach power so differently, they can't feel comfortable
in a traditional hierarchical system, so many women have been
blocked from the uppermost reaches of corporate America.
However, this latest research, which is published in the January
issue of the Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin,
found differently.
"Our study showed that, while women do wait longer to assume
a position of power, they make powerful alliances along the way.
So when they do take the leadership role, they can be just as
dominant and forceful as any men in the group," says Mast.
Moreover, she adds, women can be comfortable with power.
The idea that women may not do well in leadership positions was
born, says Mast, from differences in the way men and women approach
the decision-making process -- what many believe is a hallmark
of leadership ability.
While men are often swift in making up their minds, women take
longer to decide, considering many more factors than a man might.
"A woman boss considering a merger, for example, may be
concerned over how the move will affect the individuals in a company,
how many jobs may be lost, or how many people may suffer,"
Mast says. "These are things that men traditionally don't
consider when making a decision," she adds.
However, while hesitancy has been traditionally viewed as a stumbling
block to power, Mast says a new recognition of the difference
in governing styles should lead to a new and more equitable definition
of leadership.
The new study involved 58 men and 58 women, who were divided
into single-gender groups of four or five. They were asked to
attend two separate meetings, one week apart, where they would
discuss problems related to raising children.
Each of the two sessions was videotaped, and the participants
were interviewed privately after each meeting and asked a series
of questions about the group, including who they thought spoke
the most and who was the most knowledgeable.
Researchers then analyzed the two sets of videotapes, watching
for changes in group dynamics and interaction from the first meeting
to the second. They then compared their conclusions with the answers
on the questionnaires.
What they found: During the first meeting of the all-male groups,
a leader emerged right away, and the other men fell into a kind
of power hierarchy that easily carried over into the next week's
meeting.
In the all-female groups, researchers saw the emergence of an
entirely different power structure.
"During the first meeting, there was no clear-cut leader
-- unlike in the male groups, in the female groups, the power
was distributed evenly amongst all the participants. They each
spoke about the same, they interrupted each other about the same.
There seemed to be no leader emerging," says Mast.
By the second meeting, once the women were more familiar with
each other and alliances had formed, leaders did emerge in each
of the groups.
"What we realized was that women do assume power positions
as easily as men, just not as quickly," says Mast.
For psychologist Jason Kornrich, the new theory meshes well with
what is already known about the difference between the sexes.
"Traditionally, men are thought to be more dominant. They
have a more obvious take-control attitude, while women tend to
be more laid-back, and not so concerned with controlling everything
right from the start," says Kornrich.
"However," he adds, "this 'stop and think first'
approach sometimes results in the ultimate power, because it allows
the woman to not only know and understand those around her better,
it also helps her to form alliances that are likely to help her
in assuming her leadership role."
What To Do
For 10 interesting differences between men and women, visit the
Society for Women's Social Health Research.
To learn more about the psychological differences between men
and women, go
here or
visit the Women's Mental Health Consortium.
Reference
Source 101
For more information on how to prevent other diseases, use
PreventDisease.com's "Quick
Prevention Resources".
|