Jury
Still Out on Soccer Head Injuries
WASHINGTON (Reuters) - Soccer is not 100% safe, but it is too
soon to recommend using helmets or other safety measures to protect
children who play it, an Institute of Medicine panel reported
on Tuesday.
"Heading" a soccer ball does not usually cause enough trauma to
injure a player's head, but children dashing around a soccer field
can bash their heads together and more studies need to be done on
the dangers, the panel found.
"Even though people generally think of soccer as a safer sport
than (American) football, soccer players experience concussions
about as often as football players," the Institute, which advises
the federal government on health matters, said in its report on
children's soccer issued on Tuesday.
"A soccer ball can hit the head with significant force, and
there has been considerable debate over whether such 'heading'
also fosters brain injury."
The report said that in light of the growing popularity of soccer
in the United States, studies need to be done on just how dangerous
playing the sport can be for children.
"Soccer is probably the most rapidly growing team sport in this
country, especially for girls and women," the report said. Millions
of children and adolescents participate in youth soccer leagues
and there are hundreds of thousands of adolescents on high school
soccer teams, it added.
Of particular concern were studies done in the Netherlands that
suggest long-term brain deficits among soccer players, the panel
found.
"The Dutch studies found that, compared to swimmers or track
athletes, soccer players scored significantly lower on tests that
measured visual and verbal memory, visual analysis and planning,
and mental flexibility," the report said.
"Those test results suggest that these players would be slower
at learning and remembering new material that they hear or see,"
it added, quoting neuropsychologist Dr. Muriel Lezak of Oregon
Health Sciences University.
The report said there had been no published study to date that
provides direct evidence that the practice of heading a soccer
ball causes long-term deficits in mental functions.
University of North Carolina's Donald Kirkendall, a sports medicine
specialist, is leading a five-year study now, the report said.
In the meantime, the report included the American Youth Soccer
Organization's recommendation that children under 10 should not
head the ball, although the organization continues to support
the practice of purposeful heading for older soccer players.
Coaches and parents also need to become aware of the symptoms
of concussion, it recommended.
The Institute's panel of neurological and behavioral health
specialists issued the report after reviewing studies and reports
from experts in October
Reference
Source 89
For more information on how to prevent other diseases, use
PreventDisease.com's "Quick
Prevention Resources".
|